Write A Song : Three Chord Groups and Chord Substitution
Posted: November 21, 2013 Filed under: Songwriting, Songwriting Tips | Tags: Ascending the E Major Scale, chord substitution, three chord groups, verse/chorus type song, write a song Leave a comment Once you understand how three chord groups work, the order you play the chords in a group is up to you. You could play C, G, F, C.Or C, F, G7, C,
Or F, C, G7, C, Any order you like is fine, note that even though here we started with the F chord, the key is still C, not F.
To write a song using a three chord group in a verse/chorus type song, establish a pattern for your verse and a pattern for your chorus. A quick example using the key of G three chord group group:
Verse:
C, D7, G, G,
C, D7, G, G,
C, D7, G, G,
C, D7, G, G,
Chorus:
D7, C, D7, C,
A simple song:
Intro:
G, D7, G D7
Verse:
C, D7, G, G,
C, D7, G, G,
C, D7, G, G,
C, D7, G, G,
Chorus:
D7, C, D7, C,
Turnaround:
G. D7
Verse:
C, D7, G, G,
C, D7, G, G,
C, D7, G, G,
C, D7, G, G,
Chorus:
D7, C, D7, C,
It’s common to add a 2 minor to the 3 chord group. The 2nd note in the C Major scale is D so the 2 minor is D minor.
Play C, Dm, F, G
Another common chord to add is the 6 minor. In C that’s A minor.
So you could play C, G, Am, F, G7, C, G7, C.
To be sure you grasp the concept let’s try an example in another key, the key of E.
Ascending the E Major Scale we have:
E, F#, G#, A, B, C#, D# and E again, up an octave.
1-4-5dom7 = E, A, B7.
The 2 minor and 6 minor in the key of E are F#m and C#m.
To apply this to songwriting you might choose a chord progression for your verses and alter it for your choruses, climbs or bridge sections, play 4 beats per letter:
V1:
E, A, B7, E – E, A, B7, B7
E, A, B7, E – E, A, B7, E
C1:
A, B7, A, B7, A, B7, E, B7
V2:
E, A, B7, E – E, A, B7, B7
E, A, B7, E – E, A, B7, E
C2:
A, B7, A, B7, A, B7, E, B7
Bridge:
C#m, B7, A, A, C #m, F#m, A, B7
C3:
A, B7, A, B7, A, B7, E, E
Thinking in terms of chord progressions brings order where there once was chaos.
Now for something a bit more advanced.
CHORD SUBSTITUTION
There are thousands of chords but, according to the acknowledged authority on the subject, Ted Greene, the author of Chord Chemistry, every chord can be grouped into one of three basic categories: major, minor or 7th. If you understand that then you can start experimenting with simple chord substitution (pursue this subject very far and it gets exponentially complex).
The rule: Any chord in a category can be subbed for another in the same category provided it sounds good to the ear.
Does the sub serve the song? Does it support the melody?
Majors, major 7ths, major 9ths, major 13ths, etc. are in the Major category.
Minors, minor 7ths etc. are in the Minor category.
7ths, 9ths, 11ths, 13ths, etc. are in the 7th category.
Extended and altered chords are grouped by their root classification. In other words, generally, the first alteration to appear dominates. A B7+5 (B seventh sharp five means to raise the 5th a half step so the F# becomes a G note). But because the 7th appears first B7+5 would be classified as a 7th type. Ted groups augmented 5th chords as 7th types also.
So if you write a basic progression: C, F, C, F, G7
You could rewrite it: Cmaj7, Fmaj7, Cmaj7, Fmaj7, Gdom9th.
Another variation: Cmaj7, Fmaj7, Cmaj7, Fmaj9, GAug5
Or perhaps you have a basic D, Em, A7, D (4 beats each)
Perhaps jazz it up: D, Em7, Em9, A7, A13, D (play 4 beats on the D chords and only 2 beats on each of the Em category and A category chords)
But Em7 is a 7th type, correct? How can it sub for Em?
No. Em7 is a minor type because the minor appears before the 7th, and can indeed sub for Em.
Subs are extremely useful in certain songs in certain spots but it can easily be overdone. Get far beyond something like subbing a 9th for a 7th, which almost always works, and it tends to impart a jazzy flavor that may or may not serve the song. You won’t likely have much use for substitution in a classic rock song like Ozzy Osbourne’s “Crazy Train,” that pretty much is what it is. But most ballads in any genre can benefit as well as many uptempo pop, jazz, country swing and…well, let’s not set limits, you never know where just a single substitution might improve an arrangement. Hmmm…”I’m goin’ off the rails on a Jazzy Train?” I like it.
And remember, you only need three chords to write a hit. So if you use 5 or 6 chords obviously it will be a #1, lol.
Here is a post on the minor three chord groups.
We’re barely scratching the surface here. If you want to learn very basic open chord progressions and simple rhythms get my book Guitar Shop. If you want to learn more complicated chords, extended chords, how non-root bass notes work and learn all the chord substitution rules, get Ted’s book– bill watson
https://twitter.com/anqstyTween/status/378339521794146304
Songwriting
Posted: November 10, 2013 Filed under: Songwriting | Tags: Billboard, clever song titles, country music, songwriting, write a song Leave a comment Songwriting is a process that ultimately has no rules. On one level, if you write a song, think it’s good and like it, then it’s “good” and in theory, who can argue?On the other hand, people often argue about the quality of a specific song. This one is “great”, this one is “not very good” …who appointed them Judge of All Things Musical?
What’s certain is that generating large numbers of CD sales or paid downloads requires a lot of people agreeing a song is good enough for them to spend time and money on.
It’s weird really, any song can have avid supporters or avid detractors, yet there’s a collective mindset that determines which songs experience huge commercial success. And success is difficult to argue with.
So that’s about where commercial songwriting begins to branch off from pure art. “Rules” happen. You begin to run into gatekeepers who believe they know what “everyone likes” in a certain genre. And you better not rhyme heart with start because that’s overused cliche, that song’s going nowhere, buddy.
Unless it becomes a huge hit anyway, then for a lot of reasons that make it the exception to the rule, including the fact it was written in June and there was a moon in June, it’s okay.
Is anyone seriously going to take issue with the thought that a group of co-writers assembling at an appointed time specifically for songwriting purposes where they’ll brainstorm clever song titles and write lyrics about fictitious situations, aiming for a Billboard hit, is pure art?
And this link certainly offers food for thought:
How do you get your mind around that concept? Where does all THAT play out in your life?
The point is if you write songs you can take any of three positions:
1. I write purely for the sake of the art/fun/relaxation aspects. I don’t avoid “songwriting rules” but I don’t embrace them either.
2. I do songwriting for the art and if I accidentally write a hit, great, but no worries one way or the other. “Songwriting Rules” who cares?
3. I want a hit song! Because I want to write a hit, I “follow the rules” as much as they can be determined.
Maybe the Internet has opened things up a bit but it seems “the system” many musicians and songwriters complain about exists for a reason. Most people like a certain category of music or maybe 2-3 categories.
So if 5 million people are looking to listen to country music/purchase country music downloads, radio stations make that group a narrowly focused target. They do that because they must have money from advertisers to survive and advertisers need a targeted demographic to make spending $ pay off.
If you want to write a country hit, you must get your song in heavy rotation on the most powerful of those stations. As you endeavor to do so, the gatekeepers will be making sure you comply with rules.
Hey, life is tough no matter what you do.
That’s songwriting now and for at least the next many years to come.